|Wed 11th Sep 2019|
Vision for Polo
A realistic goal or rose-tinted glasses?
On Friday 6 September, the HPA quietly released an updated document following the circulation of the Vision for Polo consultation paper.
now to read the updated HPA Vision for Polo Consultation Paper.
The initial document, a manifesto from incoming Chairman Nick Wiles, stated his ‘vision for polo’ over the next five years, outlining what he sees as the main areas to be addressed: the development of the sport, reviewing the handicapping framework, the development of youth polo, improving behaviour and discipline, a review of governance and introducing a reviewed commercial strategy.
Following consultation with members over the past month, the Vision for Polo document has been updated with the compilation of members views and concerns. According to the HPA, the response from the polo fraternity has been extensive, with the widest range of views centred on the issues of handicapping, tournament conditions and umpiring. The main concern appears to be regarding the transparency of the handicapping policy and the fairness associated with this, but this concern does not seem to have been addressed at all in this document, with the HPA stating “In due course, once the new committees have been established, members should expect clarity as to how this will be achieved”. In our current issue, we take an in-depth look at the UK handicapping system, following on from Mark Tomlinson’s emotive article The HPA… “57 Old Farts?, first released in our publication in June 2014 and re-released this month, and following the end of this year’s high goal season. This was in response to a general feeling of ‘the need for change’, as well as in order to address the challenges our system comes up against, we spoke to four of the UK’s biggest club’s Polo Managers to get their take on the anomalies in our system.
Looking deeper into the document, the HPA propose a more cohesive strategy for regional clubs – as we all know that grass-roots polo is the beating heart of polo in the UK, a point of which the HPA are keen to shout about and not “under-estimate.” There is great care and detail taken to address the fall in regional players and support initiatives to develop a three year plan to generate membership and interest, despite ambiguous statements regarding the state of British membership.
Furthermore, in support of British players, the HPA proposes a post-Brexit rule, “that every team at every level is required to have at least one British player other than the patron”, including at high goal level. With this in mind, they also propose that team patrons and U18 overseas players adhere to a ‘no rewards’ rule, starting from the beginning of the 2020 season, but surely the attraction of U18 overseas players, such as ‘Jeta’ Castagnola and Poroto Cambiaso, free of charge, have the reverse effect?
On the extremely positive end of the spectrum, the HPA’s commitment to the development of our sport and education in polo is clear, with key factors proposed for those wishing to leave education earlier than usual to pursue a career in polo, as well as a coordinated programme across all regions to find and introduce new youth players to the sport.
Later on, the paper looks at the issues raised regarding standards of conduct, behaviour, discipline and animal welfare. With these issues being of a critical nature, the HPA appears to feel that further consideration is required and does not address the questions raised, as of yet.
With many unanswered questions, some feel the HPA is yet to address some of the most salient issues, but their willingness to open the subject to players and members is encouraging. We are all in the same boat, wanting to improve our sport exponentially, especially with the uncertainty of Brexit on the imminent horizon, but do the proposed changes go far enough? The HPA refer to introducing further committees to address a number of issues, including the three different constituencies, 22 goal, Victor Ludorum/polo at bigger clubs and regional polo, but surely this is committee introduction for the sake of committee introduction, when the governing body has 15 committees already in action? Of further, and arguably greater, concern is the process by which representatives are currently ‘invited’ to join said committees. Greater transparency is very much the order of the day – let’s hope that complete transparency is embraced so as to avoid the ‘jobs for the boys’ analogy and cries of cronyism that currently abound.
Suffice to say, it must be viewed as a positive that the HPA has recognised its short comings, but time will tell whether these proposed changes can and do come to fruition.
We would love to hear your thoughts regarding the future of our sport. Please get in touch, by clicking here
or call us on +44 (0)1452 730 770, with your views.
Tue 10th Sep 2019
RoR Racing to Polo Challenge
Winners at RCBPC
On Monday 9 September, ponies, riders and owners came together at The Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club for The Retraining of Racehorses (RoR) Racing to Polo Challenge. Ponies were awarded cash prizes for their skills and retraining prowess as part of the yearlong series, which takes place at both RCBPC and Cowdray.
RoR will be continuing their support of polo ponies, with a number of rugs and prizes in 2020. For more information about entering, please click here
The results were as follows:
Class one to three-year-olds
1st – Ireland's Angel – Sebastian Chialvo
2nd – Cheeky Lola – Nick Johnson, owned by Alan Kent
3rd – Annie's Bow – Jack Richardson
Class two to four-year-olds
1st – Whererainbowsend – Ed Hitchman
2nd – Newton Place – Adam Buchanan, owned by Aurora Cotton-Mckean
3rd – Runway Bay – Nick Johnson, owned by Alan Kent
Class three to five-year-olds
1st – Powerpuff – Ed Hitchman
2nd – No Luck Penny – Ben Eeley
3rd – Joy – Miguel Ayala owned by Pedro Harrison
Class four to six-year-olds and upwards
1st – Sweets'N'Sheets – Ed Hitchman
2nd – Mrs Frosty – Ed Hitchman
3rd – Palavicini's Girl – Rupert Lewis, owned by Richard Le Poer
Mon 9th Sep 2019
La Dolfina Victorious
Father & son secure 52nd San Jorge Open
Yesterday, Sunday 8 September, La Dolfina secured the first Open of the Argentine season in Palermo, taking home The Duke of Edinburgh Trophy.
On a beautiful sunny afternoon, father/son duo of Adolfo and Poroto Cambiaso defeated Ellerstina Pilot 9-7 to take home the first high goal handicap title of the 2019 season.
It was the first battle between old rivals, La Dolfina and Ellerstina, which could be repeated a further four times this season.
La Dolfina opened the scoring with an early penalty conversion from Diego Cavanagh, but overall Ellerstina began the match in a much stronger position and by the start of the second chukka, thanks to Facundo Pieres, Ellerstina led 4-1.
However, La Dolfina came back strong and managed to tie the scores, 5-5 in the third chukka, continuing their goal scoring spree so that the scoreboard read 8-5 at the end of the penultimate chukka. Ellerstina struggled to level the scores and the final whistle echoed around Palermo with a 9-7 win for La Dolfina.
This was Poroto Cambiaso’s first big tournament in Argentina, who at just 14-years-old faced three mighty Pieres brothers for the first time.
The Best Playing Ponies were Clone 01 Hanna Montana by Adolfo Cambiaso and Clone C06 Lapa.
Meanwhile, the Subsidiary Final was a far less balanced affair with LD World Polo League whitewashing Tortugas, 13-1.
The San Jorge Open Final Teams:
La Dolfina (30): Adolfo Cambiaso (10), Poroto Cambiaso (4), Diego Cavanagh (8) & Juan M. Zubía (8)
Ellerstina Pilot (29): Curtis Pilot (0), Gonzalito Pieres (9), Nicolás Pieres (10) & Facundo Pieres (10)
Photograph: La Dolfina, winners of The San Jorge Open. By Matias Callejo/AAP